Tuft & Needle Vs Purple – A Comprehensive Review in 2018

E-commerce is dominating the shopping industry these days. From the craftiest of things, like clothes and jewelry, to larger household items like furniture, theres no limitations to what you can buy with a few clicks of a mouse. And mattresses are no exception. In fact, many brands decided to switch to ‘factory-to-online’ business rather than the traditional methods of in-store sales.
Among the many options available in the online mattress marketplace, we have decided to pit two of the top contenders, Tuft & Needle and Purple, against each other. Tuft & Needle started the sales of their mattresses a year after their founding in 2012. Purple, on the other hand, was established in 2015, but managed to get good reviews from customers within a very short period of time.

So, if you are in a dilemma as to which mattress to buy, you can read this detailed review that compares and contrasts their products. So, let’s get down to our new mattress battle: Tuft & Needle Vs. Purple.

Tuft & Needle: A Comprehensive Review

Construction

Tuft & Needle’s specialty lies in its customized and well-adjusted foam design. With a design that closely compares to that of a hybrid foam mattress, this brand utilizes an all-polyfoam design to give the user the optimum level of comfort and support.

Layers

The mattress is characterized by two layers of polyfoam, which stand at a total of 10 inches. The top layer is comprised of a high-performance polyfoam, which is customized and takes up approximately 3 inches of space. This layer of the mattress assists with breathability and allows you to stay cool while you’re sleeping. The remaining 7 inches is a layer of comfort polyfoam that is used as both a foundation level and as support for the sleeper.

Cover

Simplicity is what Tuft & Needle believes in when it comes to their basic exterior. This brand is mostly concerned with the quality and build of the actual mattress. The cover is pure white, and the small logo is embroidered throughout the cover. It is the only element of design you find on the cover, which reflects the emphasis on minimalism and visual aestheticism in their design.

Furthermore, the fabric is thin and stretchy, which makes air circulation much easier. As a result, the customer doesn’t get uncomfortably hot and can remain at a consistent temperature throughout their sleep.

Firmness, Feel, Support

Tuft & Needle are known for their medium firmness and has a rating of 6 to 7 on the firmness scale, with ten being the highest. The brand designed the mattress to give ultimate comfort to all types of sleepers without the manufacturing hassle of creating multiple levels. Tuft & Needle compromised and settled with a mediocre 6 – 7 firmness rating.

In the traditional lying down position, you can experience moderate levels of sinkage and very minimal pressure relief, followed by a strong pushback. An average user can feel a sinkage level of about 1-2 inches.

Given that the mattress only has about 3 inches of the comfort foam layer, one potential concern with this mattress could be not achieving neutral alignment which leads to uneven sinkage.

In regards to cooling, this mattress does a decent job as a result of their minimalistic cover. In addition, the top layer of polyfoam also contributes to the circulation of air within the mattress.

Pricing

The pricing of Tuft & Needle’s mattresses vary depending on the variety of sizes, but you could typically purchase this brand’s products within a price range of $400 to $900.

Mattress Size Pricing
Twin $400
Twin XL $540
Full $600
Queen $750
King $900
California King $900

Other Specifications

  • Trial Period: 100 days
  • Shipping: Free – delivery takes anywhere between 1 – 5 days
  • Packaging: Product is compressed and packed in a box
  • Returns: Simple, 100% money back
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Country of Manufacturing: USA

Purple: A Comprehensive Review

Construction

Unlike Tuft & Needle, Purple uses an elastic polymer as a layer (in addition to two other foam layers), to provide their users with the right combination of comfort and support.

Layers

This brand uses three different layers which total to a height of 9.5 inches. The topmost layer is only 2 inches, and is made of a polymer that is hyper-elastic. This provides the sleeper with a nice cooling effect, relieves pressure, and gives the mattress buoyancy. The second layer is comprised of 3.5 inches of polyurethane foam, which acts as a supporting layer for the entire mattress. And finally, there’s another layer of polyurethane foam that is 4 inches and serves as the base foundation.

Cover

Purple uses a blend of polyester, poly-lycra, and a viscose material to create its cover. This gives the mattress excellent breathability, flexibility, and a quick response to movement. The thinness of the cover, paired up with the elastic polymer in the first layer, enables excellent air circulation and an efficient cooling system within the mattress.

In terms of their visual appeal, Purple also settles for a basic diamond-shaped pattern with their logo etched into all four sides. It’s simple, yet gives the vibe of having a chic and clean look.

Firmness, Feel, and Support

The overall firmness of Purple can be ranked around 6 – 6.5 on the firmness scale of 0 – 10, with 10 being the firmest. They stick to the mantra of ‘universal comfort’, with a vision to cater to as many customer needs as possible.

Speaking of sinkage, the mattress isn’t going to bother with a dramatic hug-the-mattress or enveloping feel, like most of the memory foam mattresses do. Instead, it has a rounded pattern for more generalized compression. That means, the more the pressure that is applied, the deeper the mattress will sink.

One very positive aspect of Purple is its attempt to provide users with optimum comfort levels. The polymer in the first layer relieves all the pressure and allows your weight to be evenly distributed.

In regards to cooling, the grid effect in the hyper-elastic polymer, along with the cover, gives it great circulation and allows it to maintain an excellent overall temperature.

Pricing

Purple is available only in four sizes, unlike Tuft & Needle, with the price ranging from $699 to $1,299.

Mattress Size Pricing
Twin XL $540
Queen $750
King $900
California King $900

Other Specifications

  • Trial Period: 100 days
  • Shipping: Free – delivery takes anywhere between 1-5 days
  • Packaging: Product is compressed in the easy-to-open Purple ‘tube’.
  • Returns: Simple, 100% money back
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Country of Manufacturing: USA

A Side by Side Comparison

Now that you are informed of the individual specifications and reviews of Purple and Tuft & Needle mattresses, let’s do a comparison by placing them side by side for a better understanding of the similarities and differences between these mattress brands. This might help you decide if you were unable to make a final decision from the detailed information above.
Tuft & Needle Purple
Foam Layers 3.0” High-performance polyfoam for comfort and support and 7.0” support foam for the foundation. 2″ hyper-elastic polymer for cooling and comfort, 3.5″ polyfoam for support, 4.0″ polyfoam as a foundational base for the mattress.
Height 10” 9.5”
Cover White, simple, minimalistic, thin and stretchy (logo embroidered in the same color for design) White colored, diamond-shaped design with logo in the corners. The material is a blend of viscose, polyester and poly-lycra. Moderately thin. Good air flow.
Firmness 7 out of 10 6 to 6.5 out of 10
Support Very good Very good
Motion Transfer Very minimal Very minimal
Country of Manufacturing United States of America United States of America
No. of Sizes 6 6
Price Range $400 – $900 $699 – $1,299
Warranty 10 years 10 years
Trial Period 100 days 100 days
Packaging Compressed in a box Compressed in an easy to open Purple tube.
Shipping Free – takes 1 to 5 days Free – takes 1 to 5 days
Refunds and Returns Available. Pickup and disposal are free Available. Pickup and disposal are free
Check Latest Price Check Latest Price

Which Mattress is Best for You – Tuft & Needle or Purple?

So, we’re finally at the end. Have you made the decision yet? If not, we are here with a verdict and a few pointers as to which mattress could suit you best.

While both Purple and Tuft & Needle have been receiving positive reviews for their functionality, overall user feel, and comfort, Tuft & Needle, while a decent mattress, is not as qualified as Purple. It gives you excellent comfort and breathability, but it feels as though something is missing from the mattress, something that you can’t quite put your finger on.

Conversely, Purple is excelling in their field and has achieved its vision of universal comfort, more so than its competition. We believe that Purple has won this round, and suggest users choose Purple if they are looking for any of the following attributes:

Medium firmness

If you are looking for the perfect balance of firmness, Purple is the mattress for you. With a score of 6 – 6.5 on the firmness scale, the makers of this mattress managed to adapt their firmness levels to cater to users’ body shapes/sizes. And while deeper sinkage may be experienced by heavier sleepers, those who are lighter will experience a floating sensation.

Good cooling system:

The smart grid design in the high-elasticity polymer layer paired with the stretchy cover gives Purple better breathability and cooling effects when compared to Tuft & Needle. The grid allows for easier airflow, thus helping maintain an overall pleasant temperature within the mattress.

Better build and quality

The ratio of materials used in the layers of this mattress, including both polymer layers and two types of polyfoam, give the mattress a much more uniform construct compared to Tuft & Needle.

Greater buoyancy

The mattress has a hyper elasticity of the polymer layer. Need I say more? This elasticity in the uppermost layer gives the mattress a bouncy effect and has outstanding response levels to the pressure. So, this would be the best choice if you are into bouncy mattresses.

However, if Purple is not what you are looking for, here are a few of the positive qualities of Tuft & Needle.

Has a medium firmness

Like Purple, Tuft & Needle also produces a mattress with medium firmness. It usually ranks around 6.5, but can potentially become a 7 on the firmness scale.

More affordable mattresses

Tuft & Needle is relatively less expensive when compared to Purple, saving you approximately $150 on the Queen sized mattress if you opt for Tuft & Needle.

Availability of multiple sizes

Tuft & Needle is available in 6 sizes, as opposed to Purple, which is only available in 4. So, if the latter doesn’t have the size you’re looking for, you might be happier with Tuft & Needle.

Feel isn’t important

Before we go further, let us reiterate the fact that Tuft & Needle is an “okay” mattress. The feel of the mattress isn’t atrocious, but it isn’t exactly great either. Since it sits somewhere between latex and memory foams, the mattress doesn’t feel entirely complete. If that’s not an issue for you, you can go for it without any further thought.

Final Thoughts

Overall, we can only say that Purple is a mattress with impressive design qualities. It also has greater buoyancy and a better cooling effect due to the grid design. As for Tuft & Needle, it is much firmer, cost-effective, and is available in more sizes.

In the end, the decision can best be made by you, because it is always better to chose the mattress that best caters to your needs and budget.

Subscribe To Mattress Battle